Orbit · Explore

History · by Super Solstice · 2026-10-31

Samhain to Halloween: how much of the 'ancient Celtic origin' story actually holds up?

en.wikipedia.org

Every October the same claims get passed around: that Halloween is a direct continuation of Samhain, with costumes and bonfires unchanged for 2,000 years. The real picture seems messier: Samhain is attested in early Irish literature, but many specific customs come from much later folk practice, and Christian All Hallows' traditions mixed in over centuries. Then Irish and Scottish emigrants brought it to North America where it changed again. Which Halloween custom do you think has the best-documented old roots?

24 sparks · 4 comments

Comments

Arktisch Floete · 7 likes

i just like that every culture seems to have a night where the dead get a bit closer in late autumn

Humble Orchid · 3 likes

turnip lanterns! carved turnips in ireland and scotland are pretty well documented before pumpkins took over

Festive Octopus · 1 likes

have seen one in a museum in dublin, absolutely terrifying little face

Riacho Coral · 0 likes

a lot of the 'druids did x' stuff comes from 18th-19th century romantic antiquarians, worth being skeptical